PDA

View Full Version : Redirect Filter vs. Forward


happety
05-21-2008, 08:49 PM
Question 1 - Is there any difference in the following?

Scenario A.
A mailbox with a filter that redirects all mail to an external account.
mailbox - me@me.com
smtp recip filter set to redirect to "me@another.com"
target recip - me@me.com

Scenario B.
A forwarding alias
alias - me@me.com
forwarding to "me@another.com"

Is the internal action the exact same and is this message received by the 3rd party (in the case, an exchange host) just the same?

Question 2.
If an alias is setup, everything is identical as in Scenario B, except the forwarding is set to two e-mail addresses, one internal and one external, does this make any difference in how the e-mail is received by the external host.
alias me@me.com
forwarding to me2@me.com, me@another.com

The reason I ask - Ideally, though I will be using an exchange account, I would still like the incoming e-mail to forward to my pop account here as well as go to the external exchange server - An alias forwarding to two account would be the way to go - I just want to make sure e-mail between scenario A and scenario B aren't handled differently by FQ or received differently by external exchange host. FYI - I don't want to tinker with MX records.

Bob
05-21-2008, 08:55 PM
Scenario A.
A mailbox with a filter that redirects all mail to an external account.
mailbox - me@me.com
smtp recip filter set to redirect to "me@another.com"
target recip - me@me.com

Any message sent to me@me.com will be forwarded, however if you have an IR then messages sent to me@ir.com would still be received in the POP account.

Scenario B.
A forwarding alias
alias - me@me.com
forwarding to "me@another.com"

All messages sent to any user named "me" will be forwarded...

does this make any difference in how the e-mail is received by the external host.
alias me@me.com
forwarding to me2@me.com, me@another.com

Not that I am aware of...

-Bob